There was a thread started by "Maximus Legis" regarding discharging of public debt in which I was posting about my ongoing dealing with the Waste Management Company I use, Panda...
The thread and Maximus seem to have left Facebook...
So I thought I'd re-post it here...
I received an invoice for x amount from Panda with a number of remittances (instructions on how to pay a debt).
I replied asking the company to confirm that they had supplied all/every remittance.
They replied with a letter re-stating the previously supplied remittances and also included "bank transfer" which had been omitted originally.
So I then replied asking for a bill...
*An invoice outlines the cost of goods/services.
*A bill informs the PERSON that they are in debt for the cost amount of goods/services.
They have replied by issuing a copy of the original invoice.
So, should I write back requesting a bill again and inform them of administrative fees they will incur should they respond with anything but a bill?
Cheers for any comments...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 718Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 718 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.Filter by poster
Read Comments 73
Pete Daoust
Scan it !!!
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 719Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 719 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
To post it here?
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 719 · cut by a page breakPrinted copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 719 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export. A page break in the printout cut off the end of this comment.
Pete Daoust
Yes :/
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720 · cut by a page breakPrinted copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 720 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export. A page break in the printout swallowed this comment: only its date was printed.
Eamonn O Brien
Gimme a few mins...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 720 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Sorry bout the delay. I had a disagreement with the printer/scanner. It has been de-comissioned :/
I've highlighted the Invoice date... I think they've just sent back the copy I sent them with my first request for remittances...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 720 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
This is what you need....
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 720 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
That's what I got in the first place... An invoice...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 720 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
It's a BILL......that gives you the opportunity to make an EXCHANGE.....
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 720 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
What BANK EAMONN OBRIEN'S SURETY is in ?
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 720 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
hang on... When I posted about this first I said I was sent an invoice with remittances and payment methods... You said I need a BILL... This is exactly what I got the first time around... An invoice. I thought the 2 were different...?
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720 · cut by a page breakPrinted copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 720 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export. A page break in the printout cut off the end of this comment.
Pete Daoust
This shit is a BILL......they write invoice, but have you ASKED for anything to them ?
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 721 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
So I didn't need to write to them asking for a bill? I had it all along...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 721 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
Yes.
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 721 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
When I first got the original invoice I asked, should I just stick a page to the back, authorise it and send it back... I was told to ask them for a bill...
So I was correct with my first instinct... Just authorise it and return...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 721 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Quick one Pete, I should send the original invoice back to them yes?
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 721 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Because it's the BoE they started from the person I control (the drawer), to them (the payee/beneficiary) to be presented to the Bank (drawee)...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 721 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
It's NOT a fucking invoice, it's a BILL OF EXCHANGE :P
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 721 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Righto... I'll get cracking with my draft completed bill and post it to double check there's no defects...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 721 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
I wrote P.T.O. on the front also...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721 · cut by a page breakPrinted copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 721 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export. A page break in the printout cut off the end of this comment.
Pete Daoust
I like the way you keep things simple, sometimes :D
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722 · cut by a page breakPrinted copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export. A page break in the printout swallowed this comment: only its date was printed.
Eamonn O Brien
K.I.S.S... :D
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Posted the completed bill yesterday... We'll see if they reply at all. No reason for them to...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Citizen Skinny Irl · Citizen Skinny
Would of been no harm Eamonn O Brien to put,,,BILL OF EXCHANGE ACT 1882 on it also.
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Panda have returned the completed bill of exchange with this note...!!
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Pete, Scott
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
They even sent back the envelope I posted the bill to them in..
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
So, what are you going to do ?? :/
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
They're clearly trying hard to get me to buy the debt.
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Scott Duncan
Send a notice acknowledging that they refused payment and that the matter is now closed.
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
A "PEREMPTORY" Notice :D
HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722 · cut by a page breakPrinted copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 722 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export. A page break in the printout cut off the beginning of this comment, with its name.
Eamonn O Brien
Fun fun... Hopefully they don't also refuse my refuse tomorrow night :/
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 723 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
CONSIDER the matter close. They need "consideration" :D
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 723 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 723 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
I get all wet on this word :/
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 723 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Scott Duncan
Dude, you are a king in this matter. ACT like it.
...and do what pete just said because he posted it as I was typing this.
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 723 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Uncertainty is a fucker though... Is it Bills of Exchange Act that outlines refusal of payment is discharge or is it a maxim?
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723 · cut by a page breakPrinted copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 723 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export. A page break in the printout swallowed this comment: only its date was printed.
Scott Duncan
Bills of Exchange Act and countless case-law examples
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 724 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
"case-law examples" , I never thought of digging this :/
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 724 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
(b) If tender of payment of an obligation to pay an instrument is made to a person entitled to enforce the instrument and the tender is refused, there is discharge, to the extent of the amount of the tender, of the obligation of an indorser or accommodation party having a right of recourse with respect to the obligation to which the tender relates.
That's from the U.C.C...
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 724 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
In civil law, the bill of exchange is strictly an abstract document, which means that the obligations arising from the document are unconditional and cannot be connected with obligations from other documents. So, under article 26 of the Geneva Uniform Law, the acceptance of a bill of exchange is unconditional. Under common law, the obligation from a bill of exchange can be made subject to performance of another obligation.
Under Geneva Uniform Law a bill of exchange can be issued on order only, while under common law a bill of exchange can be issued on bearer.
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 724 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Pete Daoust
UNCONDITIONAL. That which is without condition; that which must be performed without regard to what has happened or may happen.
:/
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 724 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Notice served... :D
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 724 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Also they collected the bin (waste/trash) this morning... :D
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 724 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Paul O'Shea · Pol O Se
Any updates on this Eamonn ??
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 724 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Nothin in the mail from them this week. Didn't need to put the bin out either... I will next Wed. I'll keep y'all posted :D
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724Printed copy from The Tender For Law Anthology, Volume 9, page 724 (printed 13 June 2014). Added by this site; not part of the Facebook export.
Eamonn O Brien
Leigh OftheHouseof Collins this is the thread about the private waste company that I dealt with... The original thread in which we discussed the fact that they are a private company and that I set up the account with them disappeared from the group for whatever reason I dunno...
Lei Gh
Thanks, Eamonn O Brien.
Eamonn O Brien
Dunno if it will be much help but there ya go...
Howard Posehn
Eamonn, was this post from early 2013. I linked to one from then but it has been removed or not found. Can you give a time frame of Max's post or a title? I'm searching through email.
Howard Posehn
From March 2013:
Maximus Legis posted in THE TENDER FOR LAW
Thoughts ? Maximus Legis 7:16am Mar 8
Thoughts ?
http://www.facebook.com/transmittingutility/posts/499800030083028
www.facebook.com
Was this the post?
Eamonn O Brien
Panda are back! :D
Despite my completion of their bill and instructing them on presentment to central bank for payment they refused it and sent it back. So I sent notice that they should consider the matter closed as payment refused discharges any debt... That was back on May 22nd...
They phoned yesterday (they've been sending texts every month since)
I told them I sent payment and they refused it. The guy asked was it a cheque or...? I said it was a completed bill of exchange and that they should contact me in writing rather than over the phone...
So they issued the SAME bill again today... Dated 15/4/2014...
Does the fact that I told them to contact me in writing open their claim back up now? Did I enter a new contract over the phone?
Or should I just send it back with this letter?
Chris Evan
Is this like the Res Judicata....or paying a bill twice? I think that is illegal
Eamonn O Brien
Should I reply at all? They received notice to consider the matter closed...
If I look at it like... They wanted money, I offered, they refused, I said ok then piss off and now they want it again...
I think I could shorten the letter right down to
"Panda refused the payment when it was offered. Consider this matter closed"
Basically the notice again... I dunno... They haven't stopped the service anyway so it's obviously just for their own profit...
Chris Evan
We need to prove they are acting in fraud...and I just don't know how yet
Chris Evan
We have this IRS form here that is called a 3949a...I havent used it yet, but I think it may be a good tool to use
Chris Evan
But, I am just not sure yet
Patrick Adams
Why can't everyone just set up a business and send themselves a billion dollar bill of exchange for payment of a product, cash it in, and be rich?
Chris Evan
Because you don't have any value
Pete Daoust
I really like the question, Patrick Adams, because it shows you are ready to learn, and there is not too much crap in your mind.... :D
Pete Daoust
I think, the reason WHY you can't do this Patrick Adams, is that you need to be ACCOUNTABLE for the credit you create....
Eamonn O Brien
Cos the account only creates debt to pay debts
Pete Daoust
In other words, books needs to be balanced at zero.......the credit you'll create through a Bill of Exchange, need to reach a DEBIT somehow, and right now. That's why Scott Duncan says, you need money (credit) when you spend it... :D
(I think) :)
Pete Daoust
Patrick Adams, please keep ASKING questions, I like these kind of questions.......there is no bullshit in them, they are raw questions.....I like it :D
Eamonn O Brien
I'm just gonna send the letter...
Pete Daoust
Send the letter back, saying: ALREADY ADMINISTRATE.
And a NOTICE in regards to your fee schedule for double administration :D
Age Thomson
ACCOUNTABLE for the credit you create..... hrmmm
I wonder when that is, that you will be held accountable, or is that to say that you must always be running balanced books so that you are ready to be accountable at any time....
Filter by poster
Read Comments 73
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 719
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 719 · cut by a page break
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720 · cut by a page break
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 720 · cut by a page break
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 721 · cut by a page break
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722 · cut by a page break
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722
Citizen Skinny Irl · Citizen Skinny
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722
Scott Duncan
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 722 · cut by a page break
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723
Eamonn O Brien
Scott Duncan
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723
Eamonn O Brien
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723
Scott Duncan
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 723 · cut by a page break
Scott Duncan
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724
Pete Daoust
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724
Paul O'Shea · Pol O Se
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724
Eamonn O Brien
Printed copy · Anthology Volume 9, page 724
Eamonn O Brien
Lei Gh
Eamonn O Brien
Howard Posehn
Howard Posehn
Eamonn O Brien
Chris Evan
Eamonn O Brien
Chris Evan
Chris Evan
Chris Evan
Patrick Adams
Chris Evan
Pete Daoust
Pete Daoust
Eamonn O Brien
Pete Daoust
Pete Daoust
Eamonn O Brien
Pete Daoust
Age Thomson
Eamonn O Brien
Pete Daoust
Chris Ó Súilleabháin
Scott Duncan
Matthew Gundry