The Accounting Lens · Lesson 6 of 8
Money is debt in transit
The idea
Apply the two-sides habit from step 2 to a bank note. In your books it is cash: something you have. Now ask whose other books it appears in. A Bank of Canada note, for example, is a liability in the Bank’s books and an asset in the holder’s. So the note in your pocket is one side of a debt, and its other side sits in the books of whoever signed it.
In Scott Duncan’s words, “A LEGAL document that bears two signatures and a TRUSTEE, is LEGALLY a SECURITY.” And “Bank NOTES, STOCKS, BONDS, are LEGAL SECURITIES.”
Money, then, is a piece of accounting on the move: “money is simply DEBT IN TRANSIT”, and “Money is based on PROMISES”, passing from hand to hand. The responsible party (surety) is the signer, who keeps the books and made the liability in them. The holder has the note but not the debt behind it: the note is a stranger’s property, and they are responsible for it only until it leaves their possession. “Cash gives you the BENEFIT but no LIABILITY (Your signature is not on it).” This is why Scott tells readers to look at the money they hold: “Notice there are names and signatures on it? NONE OF THEM ARE YOURS.”
He also separates two kinds of money: money of exchange, which buys goods and services (“MONEY OF EXCHANGE IS able to purchase consumables”), and money of account, which exists only as entries in books (“Money of account is not physical”).
A promise and an order to pay both need a signature. What differs is who is liable, and who pays. A promise binds whoever makes it, and puts a new debt in the books: “Only PROMISSORY NOTES need surety.” An order to pay directs a drawee to pay, out of an account or a debt that already stands between the drawer and the drawee. On a bill, in Scott Duncan’s terms:
- “PAYEE = BENEFICIARY”: the one paid has the benefit;
- “DRAWER = TRUSTEE”: the one who gives the order;
- “DRAWEE = SURETY”: the one who must pay.
And “If it has an ENDORSEMENT (Second Signature) it is a BILL OF EXCHANGE.”
In their words
“Money is based on PROMISES, which means so is “law”. … Your money is only as good as your law, and your law is only as good as your money.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 13, 22 February 2016
“Fiat Money is DEBT IN TRANSIT. If you can buy good/services with it, it’s MONEY OF EXCHANGE. The rest is MONEY OF ACCOUNT. MONEY OF EXCHANGE can buy MONEY OF ACCOUNT, but MONEY OF ACCOUNT cannot buy MONEY OF EXCHANGE.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 14, 23 April 2016
“SO: Banks ONLY function as a CURRENCY EXCHANGE.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 3, 3 July 2013
“Currency is no good unless other people accept it.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 10, 21 June 2015
Words to know
Check yourself
You hold a $20 note. Using the two-sides habit, name the two sets of books it appears in, and on which side of each.
Yours, as cash you have (an asset, the debit side). And the books of the bank that issued it, as a note it owes (a liability, the credit side).
Next
Trust, and the trustee: who holds things for whom.