The Tender For Law

English Only

ENGLISH is the international language of law and commerce. Knowing FRENCH is useful for understanding LEGAL ENGLISH, but FRENCH is not the international language of law and commerce, so we will ignore French speakers who speak to us in the language of a conquered people.

Non.

I understand that you are a proud Québécois, but the people here have nothing but contempt for you because of decades of transfer payments and NONE OF YOU understanding what Quebec sovereignty means. None of you know who Russell Rogers Smith is, and you're too proud and arrogant to teach. Just go away and be Retardier somewhere else.

The Accounting Lens · Lesson 4 of 8

Title is all that is sold

The idea

Everyday speech says you “own” your car, your house, your company. The lens separates three things that speech runs together:

  • Title: the record of whose name a thing is held in. In Scott Duncan’s words, “Title is all that is sold.”
  • Having the use of it: you can drive the car, live in the house.
  • A claim on it: as a lender, or as an equity holder (step 3).

Scott Duncan’s point is that registering something moves its title: “You REGISTER (transfer title) your VEHICLE, and it becomes Government (Trust) property.” So “NOTHING you “register” is owned by you.” A shareholder doesn’t own a corporation: “You are now the SOLE SHAREHOLDER (not an “owner”)”, holding a share, a claim. And whoever holds title has duties that come with it (step 7): “If you own something, you have SURETY for it.”

In the lemonade stand

Once Mia puts her $20 into the stand’s tin, the $20 is the stand’s: it is held in the stand’s name. Mia cannot own what she has no title to. What she holds is her stake, a claim on the stand. Start Here makes the same point.

In their words

“Title is all that is sold.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 1, 15 February 2013

““Property is mere TITLE”. You are only a “tennant”. You don’t OWN it like other property. NOTHING you “register” is owned by you.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 1, 8 March 2013

“You also don’t OWN a corporation (That would be SLAVERY). You CREATE a corporation, then grant ONE SHARE. You are now the SOLE SHAREHOLDER (not an “owner”).” — Scott Duncan, Volume 1, 29 March 2013

“IF YOU LIEN IT, YOU OWN IT. THAT’S WHAT A LIEN IS; OWNERSHIP OF TITLE.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 13, 22 February 2016

Words to know

Check yourself

You are the only shareholder of a corporation that holds a truck in its name. Who has title to the truck, and what do you hold?

The corporation has title: the truck is held in its name. You hold a share: a claim on the corporation, not the truck.

Next

Surety: the responsible party: who answers when what is owed isn’t paid.