The Accounting Lens · Lesson 4 of 8
Title is all that is sold
The idea
Everyday speech says you “own” your car, your house, your company. The lens separates three things that speech runs together:
- Title: the record of whose name a thing is held in. In Scott Duncan’s words, “Title is all that is sold.”
- Having the use of it: you can drive the car, live in the house.
- A claim on it: as a lender, or as an equity holder (step 3).
Scott Duncan’s point is that registering something moves its title: “You REGISTER (transfer title) your VEHICLE, and it becomes Government (Trust) property.” So “NOTHING you “register” is owned by you.” A shareholder doesn’t own a corporation: “You are now the SOLE SHAREHOLDER (not an “owner”)”, holding a share, a claim. And whoever holds title has duties that come with it (step 7): “If you own something, you have SURETY for it.”
In the lemonade stand
Once Mia puts her $20 into the stand’s tin, the $20 is the stand’s: it is held in the stand’s name. Mia cannot own what she has no title to. What she holds is her stake, a claim on the stand. Start Here makes the same point.
In their words
“Title is all that is sold.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 1, 15 February 2013
““Property is mere TITLE”. You are only a “tennant”. You don’t OWN it like other property. NOTHING you “register” is owned by you.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 1, 8 March 2013
“You also don’t OWN a corporation (That would be SLAVERY). You CREATE a corporation, then grant ONE SHARE. You are now the SOLE SHAREHOLDER (not an “owner”).” — Scott Duncan, Volume 1, 29 March 2013
“IF YOU LIEN IT, YOU OWN IT. THAT’S WHAT A LIEN IS; OWNERSHIP OF TITLE.” — Scott Duncan, Volume 13, 22 February 2016
Words to know
Check yourself
You are the only shareholder of a corporation that holds a truck in its name. Who has title to the truck, and what do you hold?
The corporation has title: the truck is held in its name. You hold a share: a claim on the corporation, not the truck.
Next
Surety: the responsible party: who answers when what is owed isn’t paid.